Guides

Ring vs Disc Magnet: Choosing Between a Bore and a Solid Pole | YUECI KEJI

A ring is a disc with a hole through it. That hole decides most of the engineering difference between the two shapes.

A ring is a disc with a hole through it. That hole decides most of the engineering difference between the two shapes.

What the bore changes

A ring's through-bore does three things: it lets the part mount on a shaft, it lets a column of flux pass through the centre, and it removes material from the middle where the flux density is lowest anyway. The result is a lighter part that often performs nearly as well as the solid disc it replaced.

The trade is manufacturability. A ring needs an ID ground to the same tolerance as the OD, which adds a grinding operation and a fixture.

Flux and force

Removing the centre of a disc removes the material that contributes least to the working flux — the flux density peaks at the surface and falls toward the middle. A ring therefore retains most of the force of the solid disc it came from, at a lower mass. The exact figure depends on the ID-to-OD ratio, which is a design variable.

Mounting and function

  • Ring wins when the part must mount on a shaft, let a pole piece or a second magnet pass through, or form a rotary encoder or coupling pole.
  • Disc wins when the part simply has to present a solid pole face — holding, stacking, sensor targets, spacer positions.

Multipole capability

Rings carry a capability discs do not: multipole magnetization. A ring can be magnetized with many poles around its circumference, which is the basis of rotor, encoder and coupling duty. A disc can only be axial, diametric or radially sectioned.

The decision

Ask whether the bore does a job. If the part mounts on a shaft or has to pass something through the centre, use a ring. If the bore is decorative, use a disc — it is cheaper to make and simpler to inspect.

Frequently asked questions

Does a ring pull as hard as a disc of the same OD? Close to it. The removed centre contributes little to the working flux, so a ring retains most of the force at a lower mass — the exact figure depends on the ID-to-OD ratio.

Are rings harder to manufacture? Yes — the ID needs its own grinding operation and tolerance, which adds cost. The bore has to earn its place.

Can a ring be magnetized multipole? Yes, and that is the main reason rings exist. Multipole rings are the standard rotor, encoder and coupling pole.

What tolerance can you hold on the bore? Dimensional tolerances are confirmed against the approved drawing and depend on part size, geometry and finishing process. Please identify critical dimensions when requesting a quotation.

If your application is covered here, Request a quote with the drawing or the duty conditions and we will confirm what is feasible.