Pull force and breakaway force are quoted constantly and understood rarely. They measure different things, and confusing them is a classic way to under-specify a magnet.
What pull force is
Pull force is the force needed to separate a magnet from a defined steel test block, measured perpendicular to the contact surface. It is the number on the catalogue: maximum, direct-contact, on clean thick mild steel.
It is also the most optimistic number in the specification, because every real departure from the test condition reduces it.
What breakaway force is
Breakaway force is the force needed to start sliding a magnet along a surface. It is a friction number — it depends on the magnet's force, the contact area, the surface roughness and any coating — and it is what matters when the load tries to drag the magnet sideways rather than pull it straight off.
A magnet that holds strongly in tension can still slide easily, which is why shear-loaded assemblies fail in ways the pull-force figure never predicts.
Why they differ
- Test block — thin, dirty, painted or alloy steel reduces both numbers; the catalogue figure assumes clean thick mild steel.
- Direction — pull is normal to the surface; breakaway is parallel to it. Different physics, different failure mode.
- Surface condition — roughness, coating and any gap change the contact and therefore both figures.
How to specify without ambiguity
State the test block, the direction, the surface condition and the required figure. 'Holds 20 kg on 3 mm painted steel, pulled normal to the surface' is a specification; '20 kg pull force' is a hope. Where the load slides, specify breakaway; where it hangs, specify pull.
The practical rule
Design with a margin against the real condition, not the catalogue number. A magnet rated at 20 kg on a perfect block might deliver a third of that on thin painted steel with a sideways load — and the assembly has to work in the real world, not the test rig.
Frequently asked questions
Which number is bigger, pull or breakaway? Usually pull, because direct normal separation engages the full force, while sliding is limited by friction. The ratio depends on the surfaces.
Does the test block matter? Enormously. Thin, dirty, painted or alloy steel reduces both figures; catalogue numbers assume clean thick mild steel.
How should I specify a holding requirement? State the test block, the load direction, the surface condition and the required figure. '20 kg on 3 mm painted steel, pulled normal' is a specification.
Why does my magnet slide instead of holding? Because the load is shear, not tension. Specify breakaway force for sliding loads and add mechanical retention where the margin is thin.
If your application is covered here, Request a quote with the drawing or the duty conditions and we will confirm what is feasible.