A disc and a cylinder of the same diameter differ in one dimension — length — and that single dimension decides most of the engineering difference between them.
The geometric difference
A disc is short: two large parallel faces and a small axial length. A cylinder is the same round section extended along the axis — stout enough to machine, long enough to carry real force. Dimensional tolerances are confirmed against the approved drawing and depend on part size, geometry and finishing process. Please identify critical dimensions when requesting a quotation.
The disc optimises pole area per unit height; the cylinder optimises magnet volume per unit diameter.
Force behaviour
Force follows the working volume and the pole area. A cylinder of the same diameter as a disc carries more magnet material, so it delivers more force — but it also presents the same pole area at a greater distance from the mounting surface, which matters in a gap. In contact, the cylinder wins; across a gap, the disc's compactness can win.
Handling and machining
Discs are the easier part to make in volume and the more fragile in handling, especially thin discs. Cylinders are more robust, easier to grind to length, and easier to hold in a fixture. Long thin cylinders approach rod territory and need support during grinding.
Where each shape wins
- Disc wins when height is the constraint — sensor stacks, voice-coil assemblies, spacer positions, anything thin.
- Cylinder wins when axial force is the point — depth sensors, actuator cores, couplings, shaft targets, anything that needs reach.
The decision
Ask whether the design is height-limited or force-limited. Height-limited designs take discs. Force-limited designs with diameter to spare take cylinders. If both are tight, a rod in a bore or a ring over a shaft usually resolves it.
Frequently asked questions
Does a cylinder always pull harder than a disc of the same diameter? In contact, yes — it carries more magnet volume. Across a gap the difference narrows, because the extra length also moves the far pole away.
Which is easier to manufacture? Discs, especially in volume. Cylinders are more robust but need length grinding and support for long thin sections.
Can cylinders be magnetized diametrically? Yes — diametric magnetization puts the poles on opposite sides of the cylindrical surface for side-acting sensor duty.
Where does a cylinder end and a rod begin? By aspect ratio. Short and stout is a cylinder; long and thin is a rod. The distinction is practical: rods need support during grinding and are usually specified by length.
If your application is covered here, Request a quote with the drawing or the duty conditions and we will confirm what is feasible.